In Mexico, the life of journalism student Lupe changes abruptly when she learns that her father, known as "El Faraón" ("The Pharaoh"), has died. In his native Colombia, he had been considered a music legend. As a result, Lupe decides to leave her native Mexico to attend her father's funeral in the Colombian city of Cartagena. Upon her arrival in Colombia, Lupe meets a mysterious young man named Noah, who turns out to have been her late father's assistant. Lupe decides to stay when she begins to suspect that her father's death was not an accident after all. She enters a music competition to investigate her late father's entourage for more information and clues about his mysterious death. In the process, Lupe must face her greatest fear: singing in public. Together with Noah, Lupe embarks on a musical adventure full of danger, mystery, intrigue, and romance. Lupe can't trust anyone, however, not even Noah, and after a long road with many false turns, she discovers the truth hidden in the heart of Colombia's Caribbean region.
Three years after the TV broadcast of the contest show "Lucas Martin Presenta: El camino del Faraón", the former contestants are reuniting to record a reunion album on Pipe's private island. Pipe is now one of the most famous rock stars in Colombia. But not only his life has changed drastically, but also that of the others: Lupe, for example, has her center of life in Mexico, where she pursues her vocation as a journalist; Noah, on the other hand, ekes out an existence in a bar he inherited from his family in Colombia. So the reunion album offers the perfect opportunity to get closer again. But the reunion is marred when a valuable necklace given to Lupe by "El Faraón" is stolen on the first night. Little by little, hidden secrets and uncomfortable truths come to light in mysterious and puzzling ways that not only cause tension between the old friends, but also threaten to leave their lives, built up over the years, in tatters.
In March 2020, it was reported that Disney+ had commissioned the musical thriller series It Was Always Me created and directed by Felipe Cano, with Leonardo Aranguibel and Cecilia Mendonça as producers.
The show was originally planned to star Tini Stoessel and Sebastian Yatra, but following their breakup they were replaced by Karol Sevilla and Pipe Bueno and the plot of the series was completely modified.
Filming of the series began in March 2021 in Cartagena and Bogotá and ended in May in Península de Barú.4
ttvnews (29 March 2021). "The Mediapro Studio comienza rodaje de nueva serie original para Disney+". TodoTVNews (in Spanish). Retrieved 14 April 2021. https://www.todotvnews.com/the-mediapro-studio-comienza-rodaje-de-nueva-serie-original-para-disney/ ↩
Disney+ Latinoamérica [@disneyplusla] (18 April 2022). "#SiempreFuiYo, Serie Original, estreno en Junio en #DisneyPlus" (Tweet) (in Spanish). Retrieved 18 April 2022 – via Twitter. https://x.com/disneyplusla/status/1516159970324144128 ↩
Maitena de Amorrortu (23 August 2022). "Ya Están En Marcha Las Grabaciones De La Segunda Temporada De Siempre Fui Yo, La Serie Original Protagonizada Por Karol Sevilla, Pipe Bueno Y Christian Tappan La Nueva Temporada Llegará A Disney+ En 2023". Disney PressPack (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 4 April 2023. Retrieved 25 August 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20230404064529/https://www.disneylapresspack.com/disney-plus/post/18224 ↩
"Disney+ comienza grabación de "Siempre fui yo" con Pipe Bueno y Karol Sevilla". Retrieved 19 May 2022. https://www.elespectador.com/entretenimiento/cine-y-tv/disney-comienza-grabacion-de-siempre-fui-yo-con-pipe-bueno-y-karol-sevilla-article/?outputType=amp ↩